Proper citation for Hewitson's "Illustrations of New Species of Exotic Butterflies"
Proper citation for Hewitson's "Illustrations of New Species of Exotic Butterflies"
Ok, so I'm not sure if this is the right place to put this. I'm trying to figure out the proper citation for the description of Falcuna libyssa. It can be found here: https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/ite ... 2/mode/1up (as Liptena libyssa).
Invariably, in publications, I see the species referenced as Falcuna libyssa (Hewitson, 1866). The trouble I'm having is that this 5th volume of Hewitson's work seems to have been published between 1872 - 1876 (at least that's what's printed on the title page... with a penciled in note that says "Pub Jan. 1 1877". Confusingly, in the page previous to libyssa's description there's another penciled in note under genus Liptena stating "Pub Jan, 1866".
Does anyone know what's going on here?
Also, there are no page numbers, how do I properly cite the page in which the description appears? Count the pages? Do I skip blank ones?
Invariably, in publications, I see the species referenced as Falcuna libyssa (Hewitson, 1866). The trouble I'm having is that this 5th volume of Hewitson's work seems to have been published between 1872 - 1876 (at least that's what's printed on the title page... with a penciled in note that says "Pub Jan. 1 1877". Confusingly, in the page previous to libyssa's description there's another penciled in note under genus Liptena stating "Pub Jan, 1866".
Does anyone know what's going on here?
Also, there are no page numbers, how do I properly cite the page in which the description appears? Count the pages? Do I skip blank ones?
- adamcotton
- Global Moderators
- Reactions:
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Tue Mar 22, 2022 12:24 pm
- Location: Thailand
Re: Proper citation for Hewitson's "Illustrations of New Species of Exotic Butterflies"
Here's how Funet cites this:
https://ftp.funet.fi/index/Tree_of_life ... e/falcuna/
Falcuna libyssa (Hewitson, 1866)
Liptena libyssa Hewitson, 1866; Ill. exot. Butts [5] (Pentila & Liptena): [66], pl. [33], f. 5-6; TL: S.Nigeria, Calabar
Adam.
https://ftp.funet.fi/index/Tree_of_life ... e/falcuna/
Falcuna libyssa (Hewitson, 1866)
Liptena libyssa Hewitson, 1866; Ill. exot. Butts [5] (Pentila & Liptena): [66], pl. [33], f. 5-6; TL: S.Nigeria, Calabar
Adam.
Re: Proper citation for Hewitson's "Illustrations of New Species of Exotic Butterflies"
Thanks Adam. Yeah, I had consulted Funet. I'm wondering how that 1866 date was arrived at. There must be some reasoning why it's that and not some year between 1872 & 1876.
Also wondering if it should be (Hewitson, 1866) or (Hewitson, [1866])?
Also wondering if it should be (Hewitson, 1866) or (Hewitson, [1866])?
- adamcotton
- Global Moderators
- Reactions:
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Tue Mar 22, 2022 12:24 pm
- Location: Thailand
Re: Proper citation for Hewitson's "Illustrations of New Species of Exotic Butterflies"
I think it should be (Hewitson, 1866) as the date of publication was not stated in the part but apparently it was printed on the wrappers. The dates of publication of each part are known, and so the year 1866 is correct. If I understand correctly, the parts were not published in numerical order, which may have produced dating anomalies.
Adam.
Adam.
Re: Proper citation for Hewitson's "Illustrations of New Species of Exotic Butterflies"
Thanks for your input Adam. I appreciate it!
Create an account or sign in to join the discussion
You need to be a member in order to post a reply
Create an account
Not a member? register to join our community
Members can start their own topics & subscribe to topics
It’s free and only takes a minute